Prologue - The Fraying Thread
Prologue - The Fraying Thread

The twelve months from January 1905 to January of 1906 was an almost unprecedented year of turnover within European royalty, one which would begin to destabilize the Concert of Powers even as the continent shifted more firmly to a model of Parliamentarianism. Denmark's Christian IX passed away as the dean of European royalty and the Empress Elisabeth of Austria died too, ending her long and strange marriage to the Austrian Emperor who was hopelessly, madly devoted to her even as she seldom reciprocated. It was three deaths, all within six months of each other, that would shape Europe moving forward though.

First of course was Crown Prince Gustaf of Sweden, whose assassination in Norway at the height of negotiations and elections to exit the Union of Sweden-Norway badly inflamed tensions and triggered the brief War of 1905, in which the large, wealthier and better-equipped Swedes invaded Norway and won a decisive victory despite encountering credible and creditable resistance along the Glomma as they pushed towards the capital at Christiania; the affair short-circuited the push towards liberal parliamentarianism in both states and reimposed not just Swedish authority in Norway but royal influence (though a far cry from absolutism, whose days were over in Scandinavia) over government in both sides of the border even as Norway was tentatively granted new privileges. When Gustaf V Adolf came to power upon his grandfather's death in December of 1907, it was as a young man deeply shaped by his father's murder and the three-month war to crush Norwegian resistance, and as a King perhaps more profoundly skeptical of modernizing liberalism than any other in Europe.

The second to go was Spain's Leopold I, who finally succumbed after years of decline and in his place appeared his son Charles Joseph I, who was like his Swedish counterpart fairly hostile to mass democracy but not so bold as to eliminate parliamentarianism entirely; what may have happened had the Spanish right not been utterly inept in its five-year hold on power is an open question, but the 1910 elections in Spain delivered a renewed National Liberal government under Jose Canalejas that moved with rapid speed to modernize Spain's most decrepit institutions and reinvigorate liberal governance and popular support for the establishment, even once-tepid opinions towards the King, who in time came to begrudgingly respect his statesman Prime Minister.

The third and most important passing though was at the end of 1905, when Napoleon IV finally died after a long pulmonary disease aged only 49. His steady hand for three decades gone, and at such a young age, was profoundly negative for France and her neighbors. With him went a commitment to the policy of the Great Detente upon the European continent, particularly between Paris and Berlin; with him also went a French reputation for competent rule and pragmatism, as his son Napoleon V rapidly showed himself more interested in prayer and consulting with archbishops than statecraft (or even his Bavarian-born wife, Helmtrud, who before long struck up a torrid affair with her chief bodyguard at her private villa in Annecy, Lieutenant Charles de Gaulle) and the indecisive but demagogic Georges Boulanger soon found himself outflanked in ambition by his protege Raymond Poincare, who wasted no time charting a considerably more aggressive course both home and abroad mere moments after Boulanger's body was cold following his February 1912 death by engaging in ill-advised brinkmanship over, of all things, the succession in Monaco.

The Monegasque Succession Crisis was one of several of the Revolutions of 1912, which were not entirely actually revolutions but rather massive social upheavals that suggested that the old status quo could no longer be sustainable across much of the Western world. In Britain, the so-called Great Unrest struck at both Ireland, now a flashpoint again as demands for Home Rule rose under the dogged leadership of John Redmond, and in industrial cities such as Liverpool or Birmingham, flummoxing the government of Richard Haldane as it struggled to juggle a weak minority government having taken power back from an inept gang of Tories. Social democrats advanced in elections across the continent, zealous liberals took power in the Ottoman Empire, Hungarian nationalists won elections and threatened to totally destabilize Austrian stability as Vienna was forced to intervene in a bizarre, farcical civil war in neighboring Serbia, and Russia's young new Tsar Michael II was forced to introduce an authoritarian constitution that nonetheless formalized modern systems of governance and delineated some rights reserved to the people. Most notably in China, wreaked by years of civil war between Qing loyalists and the Republican oligarchs that had destroyed much of the Central Plain, the First Republic collapsed after a coup by General Li Yuanhong and introduced that country's first-ever written constitution, conceived largely by former Imperial confidant Liang Qichao, though it was a constitution largely on paper; rule remained arbitrary based on local governors, nowhere more the case than in little Yunnan in the country's south, where French-backed warlords soon had total control of the province's levers of power and looked with intrigue to its vast poppy fields.

On the surface, then, the years before the eruptions of 1912 - which were punctuated by an explosion of violence in Ireland as the Haldane Liberals introduced the first Home Rule act, less Redmond bring down their government, just as Lord Hardinge, India's Viceroy, was killed in a bomb attack by the separatist Ghadar Movement - seemed placid at first yet were anything but. 1912 thus marked the turning point, where the long 19th century seemed to come puttering to an end, and the world seemed to take in a deep, nervous breath.

And that was just in Europe and Asia.
 
ITTL, the equivalent to the London/Washington Naval Treaty would look like UK/US/JP/DE/IT/MX/BR 5/5/3/3/2/2/2. (The size of the Confederate Navy having been taken care of by the treaty ending that war and the Chileans .25)
 
ITTL, the equivalent to the London/Washington Naval Treaty would look like UK/US/JP/DE/IT/MX/BR 5/5/3/3/2/2/2. (The size of the Confederate Navy having been taken care of by the treaty ending that war and the Chileans .25)
Would be floored if the US ever agreed to a WNT here.
 
Note, in regards to the CEW expanding to the New World *and* debts that Haiti owes France.

Perhaps Haiti *joins* the CEW on the German side providing a Naval port for Germany (They have more than enough coastline to have the US and Germany have separate ports) This would lead to Haiti, Venezuela (and whatever the Germans bought from the Dutch) based German ships going against Colombian based French ones.

The Peace treaty at the end would transfer some or all of the French Caribbean to Haiti. (Germany only needs so many places to grow Bananas). So Guadeloupe, Martinique, Saint Martin and St. Bart's (If France got that back) would end up being ruled by Port Au Prince. For Maximum fun, this would be viewed as the 3rd Empire of Haiti. (Of course then you need to decide if you want to use real people for Royalty. :) )
 
Note, in regards to the CEW expanding to the New World *and* debts that Haiti owes France.

Perhaps Haiti *joins* the CEW on the German side providing a Naval port for Germany (They have more than enough coastline to have the US and Germany have separate ports) This would lead to Haiti, Venezuela (and whatever the Germans bought from the Dutch) based German ships going against Colombian based French ones.

The Peace treaty at the end would transfer some or all of the French Caribbean to Haiti. (Germany only needs so many places to grow Bananas). So Guadeloupe, Martinique, Saint Martin and St. Bart's (If France got that back) would end up being ruled by Port Au Prince. For Maximum fun, this would be viewed as the 3rd Empire of Haiti. (Of course then you need to decide if you want to use real people for Royalty. :) )

Oh my god, I love this idea!!!! The creation of a costitutional monarchy in Haiti actually kind of fits the themes of this timeline - and joining the CEW to gain the French West Indies is a good match; it lets Haiti act as the 'liberator' of the local Afro-Carribbean population, and Haiti's closer relationship with the US is likely to piss off the Union less than having another European power move back into the Americas (yeah, the Monroe Doctrine is well and dead, but the US is definitely going to be flexing its international muscles a bit more after the GAW)
 
Would be floored if the US ever agreed to a WNT here.
To build on this - I entirely agree and see little incentive for the US to agree to restrict its own Navy voluntarily. That being said, there are fiscal (this war has been expensive) and strategic (the two biggest other navies in the Hemisphere are at the bottom of the ocean) reasons why the US may slow its roll on major expansion once the war is over, especially as more money will need to flow to the Army after forty years of the Navy getting everything it wants from both parties

Oh my god, I love this idea!!!! The creation of a costitutional monarchy in Haiti actually kind of fits the themes of this timeline - and joining the CEW to gain the French West Indies is a good match; it lets Haiti act as the 'liberator' of the local Afro-Carribbean population, and Haiti's closer relationship with the US is likely to piss off the Union less than having another European power move back into the Americas (yeah, the Monroe Doctrine is well and dead, but the US is definitely going to be flexing its international muscles a bit more after the GAW)
This… not a bad idea. Especially if the Spanish Caribbean gets spun off under a cadet branch crown
 
Without Hawaii or the Philippines, the US doesn't need as large of a Navy. In fact they might be *quite* willing to sign a treaty that has limits where the US is 3/4 of the UK.
Counterpoint: the US has been forced to acquiesce to the demands of the European powers to keep the sea lanes to the Confederacy open, even though it could have easily instituted a blockade by now. If that doesn't underscore the need for a larger navy I don't know what does.
Note, in regards to the CEW expanding to the New World *and* debts that Haiti owes France.

Perhaps Haiti *joins* the CEW on the German side providing a Naval port for Germany (They have more than enough coastline to have the US and Germany have separate ports) This would lead to Haiti, Venezuela (and whatever the Germans bought from the Dutch) based German ships going against Colombian based French ones.

The Peace treaty at the end would transfer some or all of the French Caribbean to Haiti. (Germany only needs so many places to grow Bananas). So Guadeloupe, Martinique, Saint Martin and St. Bart's (If France got that back) would end up being ruled by Port Au Prince. For Maximum fun, this would be viewed as the 3rd Empire of Haiti. (Of course then you need to decide if you want to use real people for Royalty. :) )
Haiti parachuting into alt-WWI and robbing France blind of its Caribbean possessions while no one is looking is a wacky idea, but undeniably a fun and unique one. Rooting for this to happen now. Speaking of Haiti jumping into wars, what are the odds they join the current one? They certainly don't lack the motivation, and any ability by the Bloc Sud to threaten them has been more or less wiped out.
 
Counterpoint: the US has been forced to acquiesce to the demands of the European powers to keep the sea lanes to the Confederacy open, even though it could have easily instituted a blockade by now. If that doesn't underscore the need for a larger navy I don't know what does.

Haiti parachuting into alt-WWI and robbing France blind of its Caribbean possessions while no one is looking is a wacky idea, but undeniably a fun and unique one. Rooting for this to happen now. Speaking of Haiti jumping into wars, what are the odds they join the current one? They certainly don't lack the motivation, and any ability by the Bloc Sud to threaten them has been more or less wiped out.
Good point.

To be honest, my thinking on Haiti all along has been that the government - formally at least - just wants to keep its head down and ride out the storm, but you can be sure plenty of Haitian volunteers have made it to US lines. But attacking French Caribbean and then making their return contingent on debt forgiveness would be hilarious realpolitik from the Haitians
 
Counterpoint: the US has been forced to acquiesce to the demands of the European powers to keep the sea lanes to the Confederacy open, even though it could have easily instituted a blockade by now. If that doesn't underscore the need for a larger navy I don't know what does.

Haiti parachuting into alt-WWI and robbing France blind of its Caribbean possessions while no one is looking is a wacky idea, but undeniably a fun and unique one. Rooting for this to happen now. Speaking of Haiti jumping into wars, what are the odds they join the current one? They certainly don't lack the motivation, and any ability by the Bloc Sud to threaten them has been more or less wiped out.
The main issue is whether Germany might want to take some or all for itself but Berlin could alternatively use it to try and make Haiti a client state (how the Union reacts is another matter entirely), leaving Haiti with debts to Germany instead of debts to France.
 
The main issue is whether Germany might want to take some or all for itself but Berlin could alternatively use it to try and make Haiti a client state (how the Union reacts is another matter entirely), leaving Haiti with debts to Germany instead of debts to France.
There was after all a very prominent German presence in Haiti that was ascendant in the islands elite
A Monarchy in CUba?

Wait, Hapsburgs in Mexico and Hohenzollern's in Cuba?

What the hell?
CdM style wild ride baby
 
Especially if the Spanish Caribbean gets spun off under a cadet branch crown
Wait, I though Cuba and the Spanish Caribbean were gonna get Commonwealth realm treatment? (By which I mean that they would be fully independent but retain the Spanish king as a figurehead with a governor-general, like Canada, Australia, and New Zealand)
 
Wait, I though Cuba and the Spanish Caribbean were gonna get Commonwealth realm treatment? (By which I mean that they would be fully independent but retain the Spanish king as a figurehead with a governor-general, like Canada, Australia, and New Zealand)
That’s 50% likely, I’d say spin-off crown 40%, insular provinces 10% at this point
 
The main issue is whether Germany might want to take some or all for itself but Berlin could alternatively use it to try and make Haiti a client state (how the Union reacts is another matter entirely), leaving Haiti with debts to Germany instead of debts to France.

Nah, we're trying to get the debt wiped out - and Haiti actively taking part in the war and taking the French carribbean would do that. Yeah, Germany might want some of those territories and likely will be able to force that in the peace treaty, but Haiti still comes out ahead. And this puts Haiti in a position to play the US and Germany off of each other in order to get the best deals going forward. And really, it makes sense considering Germany had such close relations to the Haitian uppercrust in OTL anyway - perhaps in exchange for granting Haiti some of the conquered territory, they get the Hatians to repeal thel aw which banned whites from owning land (which doesn't saddle Haiti with debilitating debt, but does strengthen the position of the German-Hatian position in Hatian society.) Throw in a Constitutional Monarchy to help bring some stability to Haiti and ... well, I think you've just made CdM a Haitian utopia (at least as close to one as we're likely to realistically see without a POD in the early 19th century.)
 
Nah, we're trying to get the debt wiped out - and Haiti actively taking part in the war and taking the French carribbean would do that. Yeah, Germany might want some of those territories and likely will be able to force that in the peace treaty, but Haiti still comes out ahead. And this puts Haiti in a position to play the US and Germany off of each other in order to get the best deals going forward. And really, it makes sense considering Germany had such close relations to the Haitian uppercrust in OTL anyway - perhaps in exchange for granting Haiti some of the conquered territory, they get the Hatians to repeal thel aw which banned whites from owning land (which doesn't saddle Haiti with debilitating debt, but does strengthen the position of the German-Hatian position in Hatian society.) Throw in a Constitutional Monarchy to help bring some stability to Haiti and ... well, I think you've just made CdM a Haitian utopia (at least as close to one as we're likely to realistically see without a POD in the early 19th century.)
Says a lot about how screwed OTL Haiti is that we’re talking about them turning into Creole Jamaica as a Utopian outcome
 
Top